Macaron vs Aider
Aider is a free, open-source pair programmer in your terminal that commits every edit to git. Macaron is a desktop app that runs Claude Code and Codex, with project checks, Git-backed undo for supported turns and optional isolation. Local work is free on Mac and Windows.
By Macaron · Updated October 16, 2026 · Other products described as of October 2, 2026
Short answer. Pick Aider if you live in the terminal, want almost any model including local ones, and like each AI edit as its own git commit. Pick Macaron if you already use Claude Code or Codex and want them in one Mac or Windows workspace with project checks and Git-backed undo for supported turns, working directly in a local folder or on an optional isolated computer.
At a glance
- Agents
- AiderAider itself, with whichever model you connect
- MacaronClaude Code, Codex and Macaron's own agent; OpenCode and Droid in a terminal
- Apps
- AiderA terminal CLI; it can watch files you edit in any editor; an optional browser UI
- MacaronA free local desktop app for Mac and Windows, the macaron CLI, and a web app at macaron.sh/app
- Models and keys
- AiderYour own API keys for almost any provider, including local models; a GitHub Copilot subscription
- MacaronYour own keys or subscriptions: Anthropic, OpenAI, Bedrock or Vertex
- Where it runs
- AiderYour machine, as you; optionally inside Aider's Docker image
- MacaronDirectly in a folder on your Mac or Windows computer, in an optional isolated Linux computer with Docker, or on a compatible server over SSH
- Undo
- AiderEvery edit is a git commit on your branch; /undo reverts the last one
- MacaronGit snapshots for supported turns, kept outside your branch history; undo refuses conflicting later edits
- Checks
- AiderLints the files it edits by default; with --auto-test, runs your test command and tries to fix failures
- MacaronProject test, lint and typecheck scripts with results to review; AI end-to-end tests with macaron e2e
- Price
- AiderFree and open source (Apache-2.0); you pay your model provider
- MacaronFree for local desktop work; Pro adds hosted services. Model subscriptions or API usage are billed separately by your provider; hosted computers use credit
| Aider | Macaron | |
|---|---|---|
| Agents | Aider itself, with whichever model you connect | Claude Code, Codex and Macaron's own agent; OpenCode and Droid in a terminal |
| Apps | A terminal CLI; it can watch files you edit in any editor; an optional browser UI | A free local desktop app for Mac and Windows, the macaron CLI, and a web app at macaron.sh/app |
| Models and keys | Your own API keys for almost any provider, including local models; a GitHub Copilot subscription | Your own keys or subscriptions: Anthropic, OpenAI, Bedrock or Vertex |
| Where it runs | Your machine, as you; optionally inside Aider's Docker image | Directly in a folder on your Mac or Windows computer, in an optional isolated Linux computer with Docker, or on a compatible server over SSH |
| Undo | Every edit is a git commit on your branch; /undo reverts the last one | Git snapshots for supported turns, kept outside your branch history; undo refuses conflicting later edits |
| Checks | Lints the files it edits by default; with --auto-test, runs your test command and tries to fix failures | Project test, lint and typecheck scripts with results to review; AI end-to-end tests with macaron e2e |
| Price | Free and open source (Apache-2.0); you pay your model provider | Free for local desktop work; Pro adds hosted services. Model subscriptions or API usage are billed separately by your provider; hosted computers use credit |
How each works day to day
Aider
You run aider in a git repository, add the files you want it to work on, and chat in the terminal. It edits the files and commits each change with a descriptive message, marking itself as the author. Ask mode answers questions without editing, and architect mode has one model plan the change while an editor model writes it. With watch mode on, a comment ending in AI! in any editor sets it to work.
Macaron
Open a local folder on Mac or Windows, or choose an optional isolated computer, and start Claude Code or Codex using your own provider account. Review shows the diff, project checks help verify changes, and Git-backed undo can reverse a supported turn unless later edits conflict.
Undo and your git history
Aider's undo is git itself: every edit becomes a commit on your branch, and /undo removes the last commit Aider made. You get a full record, and you squash or keep those commits yourself. You can turn auto-commits off.
Macaron keeps its checkpoints in separate git refs, so your branch only has the commits you make. Undoing a turn restores the files from before it, and Macaron refuses if a later edit would conflict.
Where code runs and what it can touch
Aider runs on your machine with your permissions and asks before shell commands it suggests, unless you pass --yes-always. Its Docker image runs it, and the commands it runs, inside a container instead.
Macaron's Computers are Linux machines with no access to your Mac's files, keys or Docker socket. A sandbox copy of a folder works there, and Apply to Mac writes the result back only if it applies cleanly.
Tests and checks
Aider lints the files it edits by default. Set --test-cmd with --auto-test and it runs your tests after each change and tries to fix whatever fails, in a loop you can watch.
Macaron uses the test, lint and typecheck scripts available in your project and shows the results for review. You can hand a failing check back to the agent; review the result before keeping its changes.
Pricing
As found on aider.chat and GitHub on October 2, 2026.
Aider is free and open source under Apache-2.0, with no paid plans on its site. You pay your model provider directly. Its latest tagged release on GitHub was v0.86.0, from August 2025.
Free for local desktop work; Pro adds hosted services. Model subscriptions or API usage are billed separately by your provider; hosted computers use credit.
Who should pick which
- You work in the terminal and your own editor, and don't want another app: Aider.
- You want local models, or a provider Claude Code and Codex don't support: Aider.
- You want every AI edit as a commit on your branch: Aider.
- You already pay for Claude or ChatGPT and want Claude Code or Codex themselves: Macaron.
- You don't want the agent running on your Mac at all: Macaron, with a sandbox copy and Apply to Mac.
Using both
Both work on an ordinary git repository, so you can open the same project in either. You can also run aider in a terminal tab in Macaron; the turn cards, undo and checks are for the agents Macaron runs in its chat.
What Macaron doesn't do
Macaron is single user, with no mobile app, shared workspaces or hosted SLA. Agent-provider subscriptions and API usage are separate. It also has no voice input and no mode that works from comments in your editor, as Aider's watch mode does.
Questions
Is Aider free?+
Yes. Aider is open source under Apache-2.0 and had no paid plans on its site on October 2, 2026. You pay for the models you use.
Can Aider use my Claude subscription?+
Aider's docs describe API keys for Anthropic and other providers, a GitHub Copilot subscription, and a copy-and-paste mode for web chat apps. Macaron runs Claude Code, which signs in with your Claude account.
Which one keeps my git history cleaner?+
Aider commits every edit to your branch, which some people want as a record. Macaron keeps its checkpoints outside your branch, so history has only the commits you make.
Can I run Aider inside Macaron?+
Yes, in a terminal tab. Macaron's chat, turn cards and undo are for Claude Code, Codex and its own agent.
Sources and dates
- aider.chataider.chat, read October 2, 2026
- Aider docs: git integrationaider.chat, read October 2, 2026
- Aider docs: linting and testingaider.chat, read October 2, 2026
- Aider docs: chat modesaider.chat, read October 2, 2026
- Aider docs: connecting to LLMsaider.chat, read October 2, 2026
- Aider docs: Dockeraider.chat, read October 2, 2026
- Aider on GitHubgithub.com, read October 2, 2026
Facts about other products come only from these pages, on the dates shown; prices are as published that day. Macaron's details reflect the app and documentation reviewed for this guide on October 16, 2026. Products change, so check their sites for the latest.